[AEJMC Newspaper Division list] New name for Newspaper Division?

Thu Jul 17 14:18:39 CDT 2008

Hi all,

After nearly a decade of being involved in division affairs, I believe that
one of the strengths  of AEJMC is the great diversity of its divisions and
interest groups. The numerous divisions and interest groups, however, have
long been viewed by some as a weakness that undermines central authority.
Some say it is messy; others say it doesn't work. But I say the divisions
and interest groups give voice to many views and bring democratic processes
to the table. They encourage participation, often passionate, from the
membership. Overall, I am concerned about the push in the proposed strategic
plan to "restructure" AEJMC and to "streamline," "combine," or "merge" the
various divisions.

Instead of viewing "newspaper" as a weakness, I would suggest that the the
newspaper division remains one of the strongest and most effective
divisions. This is evident by the varied programming, membership and
research offerings.  We also publish the "NEWSPAPER Research Journal." It
seems like a fine name to me. My students still get jobs at newspapers.

I also would argue that the current structure of AEJMC is sound:

1) By providing so many divisions and interest groups, AEJMC creates a sense
of inclusion and belonging while it maximizes research and professional
development opportunities for junior faculty.

2) The current structure diffuses power and encourages self-governance.

I'm glad Susan had brought this conversation forward. And I encourage all of
you to attend the Newspaper Division business meeting in Chicago and to
attend the convention business meeting, which will discuss the strategic
plan for AEJMC. These are important conversations.

See you in Chicago,
Glen

Chair and co-chair, Council of Divisions, 1999-2003;
Head, Newspaper Division,  1998-1999.
Chair, Graduate Education Interest Group, 1992‑93; Founding member of
interest group.

From: "Edward C. Pease" <ted.pease at usu.edu>
Date: Thu, 17 Jul 2008 10:57:45 -0600
To: "susank at scils.rutgers.edu" <susank at scils.rutgers.edu>
Cc: "news-list at aejmc.net" <news-list at aejmc.net>
Subject: Re: [AEJMC Newspaper Division list] New name for Newspaper
Division?

Dear Newspaper Division:

I feel Susan Keith's pain over the possible renaming (rebranding?) of the
Newspaper Division, as we all struggle with how to define what "newspaper"
people now do in the brave new world where print is dwindling and "news"
doesn't mean what it used to.

I'm a former Newspaper Division head and longtime member, as well as a
longtime newspaperman. That is a term that reminds me of this from an editor
in the 1990s: "Being a reporter is like being a cowboy on a dinosaur ranch."

It may be that the newspaper is an obsolete term like "daguerreotype," but
what "newspaper" means for me still stands for a lot--newsgathering,
sense-making, watchdoggery and all the rest (even if fewer and fewer of
Americans write and read).

As painful as it would be, changing the name of the Newspaper Division makes
sense in many ways, for the reasons Susan suggests. But if we're going to do
it, expanding the name to enumerate delivery systems such as "online" is
just clutter. What we who teach and study newspapers and news is news--not
the paper or online or text-messaging or other parts.

When the Association for Education in Journalism (AEJ) debated its
name-change to become more inclusive, the argument was similarly
commonsensical: the field was evolving beyond just the "journalism" part. At
the time, however, I thought expanding AEJ to AEJMC was an idea in need of
an edit--adding "mass communication" to "journalism" was like calling
ourselves the Association of Apples and Other Fruit. Redundant. But how
could we delete the "journalism" part of the name? it's fundamental.

Similarly, the Newspaper Division is fundamentally about news and, as Susan
says, not just about papers. The news business is converging, after all, to
incorporate lots of delivery systems. So perhaps instead of redundant
add-ons about online and new media, perhaps we should talk to our broadcast
colleagues and create an even bigger 600-pound gorilla  within AEJMC, the
News Division. Inclusivity is not only good, but essential to what we do. 

Yrs in curmudgeondom,
Ted Pease

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 
Edward C. Pease, Ph.D
Professor & Graduate Coordinator
Book Review Editor, Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly
Department of Journalism & Communication
Utah State University
Logan, Utah 84322-4605
435-797-3293; 435-797-3973 FAX; 435-760-1707 (cell)
www.usu.edu/journalism/faculty/pease
Subscribe (free!) to TODAY'S WORD ON JOURNALISM
(http://tedsword.blogspot.com/) at ted.pease at usu.edu See
also.... http://askdrted.blogspot.com/ . . . http://peezpix.blogspot.com/ .
. . http://newshounds1.blogspot.com/
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
"Words are sacred. They deserve respect. If you can get the right ones in
the right order, you can nudge the world a little." --Tom Stoppard

On Jul 17, 2008, at 9:16 AM, Susan Keith wrote:

> Dear Newspaper Division colleagues,
> 
> I'm writing to ask you to consider an issue that the division's executive
> committee will be discussing next month in Chicago: whether   the Newspaper
> Division of AEJMC should consider changing its name.
> 
> In the July issue of our division newsletter, LeadTime, I argued that -- in
> keeping with AEJMC's focus this year on the future of our field -- our
> division should expand its name to clearly indicate that it embraces the
> study of online and other types of journalism practiced by newspaper
> companies. If you are away from the location where you receive your mailed
> copy, you can download a PDF of the newsletter from
> http://aejmc.net/newspaper/leadtime/leadtime_july_2008.pdf But I will
> briefly recap my reasons for suggesting a name change here:
> 
> 1. "Newspaper" no longer accurately describes the full range of products
> that traditional print journalism outlets are producing.
> 
> 2. "Newspaper" no longer accurately describes the full range of journalistic
> work that our division members study. At the Chicago convention, we will
> hear research presentations on newspaper online interactivity, copy editors'
> roles in the "digital revolution," online citizen journalism and reporters'
> blogs.
> 
> 3. Giving the division a name that accurately reflects the breadth of our
> interests might help us stem a decline in membership. Although the Newspaper
> Division remains the largest in AEJMC (by just 20 members), membership has
> fallen 13.3 percent since 2004, from 684 to 593. It's impossible to say for
> sure what caused the decline, but it's possible that some AEJMC members are
> not joining our division or renewing membership in it because they think all
> we are concerned with is what some view as a dying medium. (I don't share
> that view, but it is out there.)
> 
> 4. Giving the division a name that accurately reflects the breadth of our
> interests might help us stem a decline over the past few years in paper
> submissions. Again, it's impossible to say for sure why our submissions have
> been down, but it may be that scholars studying such topics as online news
> sites, for example, have perceived our division as being focused only on
> news printed on paper.
> 
> 5. Expanding our division's name to something like "Newspaper and Online
> Journalism Division" or "Newspaper and Newer Media Division" -- or some
> better name members suggest -- would let us offer a division home to the
> scholars who study online and newer media journalism. Some of those people
> are now affiliated with AEJMC's Communication Technology Division. But for
> others, whose work is focused more on *journalism* than *technology,* that
> division may not seem like the perfect fit.
> 
> 6. Expanding our division's name might help us better weather any internal
> reorganization that grows out of adopting the AEJMC Strategic Plan, which
> members will be asked to vote on in Chicago. (You can read more about it,
> from my perspective, here:
> http://aejmc.net/newspaper/leadtime/leadtime_march2008.pdf.)
> 
> A few of you have already responded to my print column explaining why you do
> or do not support a name change. I will be sharing your opinions with the
> membership via this list (unless you asked me not to). I hope that this note
> in your e-mail box will prompt more of you to respond and share your
> opinions about whether changing the division's name is a good idea and, if
> so, what the new name should be.
> 
> You can share your thoughts by sending a note to the Newspaper Division
> e-mail list at news-list at aejmc.net  I hope you'll share your opinions
> publically, but if you'd rather send them just to me, you may do so at
> susank at scils.rutgers.edu.
> 
> I look forward to hearing from you!
> 
> Susan Keith, Ph.D.
> 2007-2008 AEJMC Newspaper Division head
> Assistant professor
> Department of Journalism and Media Studies
> School of Communication, Information and Library Studies
> Rutgers, the State University of New Jersey
> 4 Huntington Street
> New Brunswick, NJ 08901
> (732) 932-7500, ext. 8235
> susank at scils.rutgers.edu
> www.scils.rutgers.edu/~susank
> Office: CILS 106
> 
> 
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> News-list mailing list
> News-list at aejmc.net
> http://aejmc.net/mailman/listinfo/news-list_aejmc.net
>  

_______________________________________________
News-list mailing list
News-list at aejmc.net
http://aejmc.net/mailman/listinfo/news-list_aejmc.net

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://aejmc.net/pipermail/news-list_aejmc.net/attachments/20080717/c97c0bf5/attachment.html 